Pay Deposit Online




Pay Deposit Online




Locally and Family Owned | FREE Consultations | Fresh, Farm-to-Table Ingredients


Our Story

Get a Taste of the Classic Long Island BBQ

BBQs don’t just come with delicious, classic foods. They have a whole air of summertime fun about them! Count on the team at Holly’s Catering to cater your next party or special event with everything you need to have the best Long Island BBQ you could imagine.

We prepare all of your food fresh the day of your event. Our farm-fresh ingredients are locally grown at Deer Run Farms in Brookhaven, NY. If you or any of your guests have special requests or dietary restrictions, such as a gluten intolerance or vegan diet, just let us know and we’ll be happy to accommodate your needs. Contact us today to start planning your next BBQ!

Dinner Menu

Discover the Features of Our Classic Long Island BBQ

BBQ Menu

  • Butcher-fresh hot dogs
  • Black Angus hamburgers
  • Marinated grilled chicken
  • Baked beans
  • Long Island farm-fresh corn with butter
  • Field greens with white balsamic vinaigrette
  • Watermelon
  • Pork ribs 
  • Pull pork sliders 
  • BBQ chicken 
  • Italian ice tubs (great for kid parties and large events)
    Additional Options / Add-Ons
    • Potato salad
    • Coleslaw
    • Macaroni salad
    • Kebabs
    • Sautéed onions
    • Peppers
    • Cornbread
    Condiments and Supplies Included
    • Lettuce
    • Tomatoes
    • Onions
    • Pickles
    • Saurkraut
    • Burger and hot dog buns
    • Ketchup and mustard
    • Plastic tablecloths, all paper goods, serving utensils, and platters


      What People are Saying

      the food was superb

      Holly you and your staff are amazing thank you thank you for making a perfect party ….the food was superb staff was friendly and professional your clean up was over the top ……

      Dawn and JOHN R

      incredibly accommodating

      Holly was fantastic and incredibly accommodating. We wanted to do a very small (due to COVID concerns) dinner party. Most caterers won’t even consider doing an event with fewer than 10 people. 

      Jennifer S

      Everyone was pleasantly surprised

      Holly and her crew were amazing from my first interaction with them to the last. Everyone was pleasantly surprised about how much food their was, and how stuffed they were at the end of the night! 

      Stephanie W

      exceptional from start to finish

      My recent experience with Holly was exceptional from start to finish. She gave me exactly what I was looking for and provided many additional options and choices along the way at an exceptionally fair cost given the quantity and quality of food, preparation, cooking and cleanup.  

      Deneen C