Pay Deposit Online




Pay Deposit Online



Dinner Parties

Locally and Family Owned | FREE Consultations | Fresh, Farm-to-Table Ingredients


Our Story

Exceptional Catering for Dinner Parties

Ensure your next dinner party is an absolute success with help from Holly’s Catering. Holly’s Catering is an owner-operated business that’s backed by 40 years of industry experience. Our mature, professional wait staff is on-site for every catering service so that your event goes perfectly.

Contact us today for details about our services and options, and speak with us about your next party, event, or special occasion. All of our produce is local and freshly picked at Deer Run Farm Stand in Brookhaven, NY. Gluten-free, vegan, and fish-allergy options are readily available. Count on us for the high-quality service and fantastic food you deserve.

Dinner Menu


Our Caterers are an amazing choice for:

  • Graduation parties
  • Engagement parties
  • Bridal showers
  • Corporate parties
  • Cocktail parties
  • Milestone birthdays
  • Divorce parties
  • Breakfast parties
  • Dinner parties
  • Strategy session events
  • Passover
  • Yom Kippur
  • Hanukkah
  • Weekend off-site parties / events
  • Gender reveal parties
  • Beach parties

Thanksgiving Dinner Menu

  •  Basted Golden Brown Turkey 
  • Honey Baked Ham
  • Old Fashioned Corn Bread Stuffing (Pork Sausage can be added) 
  • Fresh Mashed Potatoes 
  • Roasted Red Potatoes w/ Rosemary
  • Roasted Fingerling Potatoes w/Parsley
  • Fresh Sweet Potatoes w/ Marshmallows 
  • Roasted Brussels sprouts w/Pancetta & Walnuts
  • Sweet Cream Rutabaga 
  • Candied Carrots 
  • Steamed Carrots 
  • String Beans Almandine 
  • Steamed Asparagus 
  • Home Made Cranberry Sauce 
  • Home Made Apple Sauce 
  • Farm Fresh Pies 
  • Apple, Pumpkin, Berry


What People are Saying

the food was superb

Holly you and your staff are amazing thank you thank you for making a perfect party ….the food was superb staff was friendly and professional your clean up was over the top ……

Dawn and JOHN R

incredibly accommodating

Holly was fantastic and incredibly accommodating. We wanted to do a very small (due to COVID concerns) dinner party. Most caterers won’t even consider doing an event with fewer than 10 people. 

Jennifer S

Everyone was pleasantly surprised

Holly and her crew were amazing from my first interaction with them to the last. Everyone was pleasantly surprised about how much food their was, and how stuffed they were at the end of the night! 

Stephanie W

exceptional from start to finish

My recent experience with Holly was exceptional from start to finish. She gave me exactly what I was looking for and provided many additional options and choices along the way at an exceptionally fair cost given the quantity and quality of food, preparation, cooking and cleanup.  

Deneen C